Former Newcastle United striker Alan Shearer has offered his perspective on the prospect of Eddie Howe succeeding Michael Carrick as manager of Manchester United. With Carrick facing immense scrutiny following a poor run of form, reports have linked the unemployed Howe with taking over the helm at Old Trafford.
Shearer Defends Carrick Amid Poor Results
Carrick finds himself under mounting pressure and is viewed as a leading candidate to become the initial Premier League manager dismissed this season. Manchester United have claimed victory in only two of their first eleven fixtures this term, an alarming sequence compounded by a 4-1 loss to Como on Wednesday. A negative outcome against Bournemouth this weekend could bring an end to Carrick’s tenure.
Despite acknowledging the grim results, Shearer expressed sympathy for the current manager during a conversation with Betfair. He pointed out that the frequent managerial turnover reflects wider institutional failings rather than coaching deficiencies alone.
Shearer stated that whatever occurs at senior executive level inevitably influences performances on the pitch, adding, “I mean, it can’t be a coincidence. Manchester United keep going through manager after manager after manager, looking for a solution. The club is awful in terms of the way it is.”
The pundit acknowledged that Carrick guided the team into the Champions League last season, but noted that recruitment problems have persisted. Shearer remarked that while United remain a massive institution, they are no longer an elite side on the pitch, having missed out on their primary transfer targets over the summer window.
Warning for Howe and Prospective Replacements
A report published on Friday suggested that Manchester United technical director Jason Wilcox has identified Howe as his preferred choice to take the reins. Howe has remained unattached since parting ways with Newcastle over the summer.
Shearer cautioned that incoming managers face deep-rooted structural turmoil. He pointed to the club’s turbulent recent history involving Ralf Rangnick, Erik ten Hag, and Ruben Amorim, alongside disruptions surrounding Dan Ashworth’s compensation from Newcastle, Dave Brailsford, recruitment shortcomings, and internal disputes regarding ticket pricing.
Addressing prospective candidates, including Antonio Conte and Howe, Shearer questioned whether Old Trafford represents an appealing environment under current circumstances. He observed that Howe specifically prioritizes having control over key matters, leaving uncertainty over whether the club hierarchy would grant him such authority.







