Football365 has released its selection for a Premier League overrated XI, highlighting players whose public praise and popularity exceed their true quality. The feature includes well-known names from top clubs across the league, ranging from Arsenal and Manchester United to Manchester City and Tottenham.
Goalkeeper and Defenders
In goal, Chelsea’s Emi Martinez is noted as an upgrade on Robert Sanchez following his move to the Blues, yet he fails to replicate his Argentina form at club level and has shown error-prone tendencies with some suspect goals conceded. Newcastle United right-back Tino Livramento is viewed as limited offensively while drawing questions over previous reported transfer interest from Manchester City and Arsenal. Chelsea center-back Levi Colwill remains unconvincing despite high expectations, needing improvement in defensive awareness and pace. Tottenham’s Micky van de Ven is described as heavily reliant on his blistering pace to mask defensive shortcomings, while Fulham left-back Antonee Robinson enters the lineup as a player whose long-standing underrated status may have swung too far the other way.
Midfielders and Forwards
In the middle, Tottenham’s Lucas Bergvall presents a tricky profile to nail down regarding his specific role and attributes, though he retains time on his side at 20 years old. Crystal Palace midfielder Adam Wharton is praised as a tidy player, but the publication questions comparisons to Toni Kroos given his absence from the England squad and a lack of actual big-money movement from clubs like Manchester United or Chelsea. Out wide, Arsenal’s Bukayo Saka is described as having lost his pace and explosiveness after being heavily relied upon by Mikel Arteta. Manchester United captain Bruno Fernandes faces criticism for his negative body language and high-risk passing style during difficult periods. Manchester City’s Phil Foden sees his stock lowered since his 2023/24 standout campaign alongside a poor international record of four goals in 49 games. Up front, Sunderland’s Brian Brobbey edges out Igor Thiago due to his physical throwback style, despite a return of seven goals in the 2025/26 Premier League season.
The feature notes that evaluating players as overrated involves subjective opinions on public praise and popularity exceeding true quality, while acknowledging the inherent difficulty of critiquing professional athletes.







