Manchester United are facing another managerial crisis following a 3-0 home defeat against Bournemouth, extending their winless streak to eight matches. As supporters applauded current manager Michael Carrick before directing boos toward the squad, Football365 compiled an assessment ranking the eight permanent and long-term managers who have taken charge at Old Trafford since Sir Alex Ferguson stepped down in 2013.
The Struggles at the Bottom: Carrick and Amorim
Carrick occupies eighth spot in the analysis, designated as the least successful permanent appointment of the post-Ferguson era. In his permanent spell this season, United have managed only a single victory across eight Premier League fixtures, conceding 13 goals and suffering three defeats. Additional setbacks include Champions League losses against Como and Atletico Madrid, alongside an elimination from the Carabao Cup against Brighton after surrendering a 2-0 advantage. The evaluation noted that while tactical shortcomings have made Carrick’s position precarious, wider organizational questions surround club executives Jason Wilcox and Omar Berrada.
Ruben Amorim sits in seventh position following an unsettled 14-month tenure. The Portuguese tactician oversaw an embarrassing slide to a 15th-place finish during the 2024/25 season. His refusal to abandon a failing formation, along with public criticism of both players and media pundits, ultimately sealed his departure while raising questions regarding recruitment overseen by co-owner Sir Jim Ratcliffe.
Mid-Table Tenures: Moyes, Rangnick, and Ten Hag
David Moyes ranks sixth after lasting just 10 months into a six-year deal. Despite inheriting a championship-winning squad upon Ferguson’s recommendation, Moyes struggled to maintain competitive consistency, finishing seventh in the Premier League, with a Community Shield victory over Wigan Athletic providing his sole silverware.
Ralf Rangnick stands in fifth place. Initially appointed to steady the team in 2021/22 following the dismissal of Ole Gunnar Solskjaer, the German was intended to transition into an advisory role. That consultancy never materialized after Erik ten Hag chose not to collaborate with him. Rangnick famously diagnosed that the squad required “open-heart surgery,” as United finished sixth, ending the campaign 13 points behind the top four before he departed to take over the Austrian national team.
Erik ten Hag takes fourth position in the ranking. The Dutch manager captured the Carabao Cup and achieved a third-place league finish in his debut season, followed by an unexpected FA Cup triumph over Manchester City in his second year. However, his tenure deteriorated due to an eighth-place league finish, a group-stage exit from the Champions League, and ineffective summer recruitment, prompting Ratcliffe to dismiss him early in his third campaign.
The Top Contenders: Van Gaal, Solskjaer, and Mourinho
Louis van Gaal is placed third. While the Dutchman drew criticism for a pragmatic and often uninspiring possession-heavy style of play, he provided memorable press conferences and secured the 2016 FA Cup, the club’s first trophy of the post-Ferguson period, before being dismissed immediately after the final.
Ole Gunnar Solskjaer claims second spot, with the assessment noting that Manchester United produced their most entertaining attacking football of the modern era under the Norwegian. Initially taking charge on an interim basis that included a memorable Champions League comeback against Paris Saint-Germain, Solskjaer oversaw fluid counter-attacking play and extracted peak performances from Bruno Fernandes and Anthony Martial before being dismissed in November 2021.
Jose Mourinho leads the rankings as the most accomplished manager at Old Trafford since 2013. During his initial season, the Portuguese guided the club to victories in the Carabao Cup and the Europa League, which secured qualification for the Champions League despite a sixth-place league finish. Mourinho followed that by securing second place in the Premier League the subsequent year, which he described as the greatest achievement of his career, before his stint concluded with his sacking in December 2018.







