Manchester United legend Paul Scholes has stated he would immediately sell Bruno Fernandes and Lisandro Martinez, while former Liverpool captain Steven Gerrard has identified seven players he believes are not good enough for the club following a difficult start to the season.
Scholes targets Fernandes and Martinez
Optimism was high at Old Trafford at the conclusion of the previous campaign after Michael Carrick secured the permanent head coach position following a third-place finish in the Premier League and qualification for the UEFA Champions League. However, the situation has deteriorated by the end of October, with speculation growing that Carrick is facing the prospect of being dismissed by club leadership.
The team suffered a 3-0 defeat against Bournemouth, which followed a 4-1 loss to Cesc Fabregas’s Como side in midweek. Following the match against the Serie A team, club captain Fernandes publicly criticized the tactics of Carrick and his coaching staff, drawing heavy criticism from former players and pundits.
This incident followed comments made the previous week by defender Martinez, who argued that the club hierarchy had failed to provide Carrick with adequate support during the summer transfer window.
Appearing on the Good, the Bad & the Football podcast alongside host Paddy McGuinness, Scholes named Fernandes and Martinez when asked which players he would remove from the squad due to toxic behavior. Speaking to McGuinness, Scholes explained his reasoning.
Scholes stated regarding Fernandes: “Well, from what Bruno Fernandes did last week, I think that was unforgivable. So Bruno’s one.”
Addressing Martinez, Scholes added: “Martinez for what he said as well. I’m not saying it’s wrong what he said, but it’s not his business. That is nothing to do with you.”
Gerrard evaluates struggling squad members
Meanwhile, Steven Gerrard assessed the Manchester United roster during an appearance on Overlap Daily, highlighting seven players he feels do not meet the standards required for the club.
Gerrard described Fernandes as a terrific and talented footballer, noting that he is a pleasure to watch when performing at his best despite being a Liverpool supporter. However, Gerrard argued that several other squad members should have been moved on earlier.
Gerrard said of defenders Harry Maguire and Luke Shaw: “Harry Maguire’s had a really good career, Luke Shaw, I played with Luke, he was top in his day. They’re not Manchester United players anymore. They should have been moved on quicker.”
Regarding Martinez, Gerrard alleged that the defender focused primarily on the World Cup last year, returned dissatisfied with the club’s summer acquisitions, spoke out publicly, and subsequently got injured. Gerrard remarked that the situation stinks.
Moving to the midfield, Gerrard questioned the £50 million signing of Andrey Santos from Chelsea, stating he is not a Manchester United player. He also discussed £70 million signing Carlos Baleba, suggesting that while the player has potential, he is not currently ready to help the team compete at the top of the league.
On the flanks, Gerrard criticized the wide areas by comparing them to past teams featuring world-class players like Ryan Giggs and David Beckham. He described young winger Amad Diallo as inconsistent, stating he has shown nothing this season, and noted a complete lack of output from the left side of the pitch.
Discussing the forward line, Gerrard praised Bryan Mbeumo as a good player and one of the shining lights of the season, but raised questions about Matheus Cunha being dropped. Gerrard asked whether Cunha is failing to train properly or acting as a toxic influence, noting that a recently signed Brazil international should be starting.
Gerrard concluded by mentioning that Benjamin Sesko is currently injured and not good enough, summing up that the club faces problems all over the pitch.







