Michael Carrick has faced criticism for making a “silly” decision by dropping Manchester United captain Bruno Fernandes to the bench. The midfielder reportedly held face-to-face talks with the manager to resolve the issue ahead of their upcoming fixture.
Pundits Criticize Decision on Fernandes
Carrick left his captain out of the starting lineup for the 3-0 defeat against Bournemouth on Sunday, a match that immediately followed a 4-1 Champions League loss to Como. Reports indicated Fernandes was benched after criticizing Carrick’s tactics following the European defeat.
While Carrick insisted the omission was a “pure football decision,” pundits argued the handling of the situation was flawed. Speaking to talkSPORT, Danny Murphy criticized the approach, stating that benching their best player and refusing to bring him on when the team was losing was a mistake.
Murphy said, “He’s your best player and [Carrick] could’ve given him a rollicking in front of the boys regarding the comments, which were ill-advised and bad timing with everything going on.”
Murphy added, “If you’ve got no intention of bringing him on and you’re punishing him, don’t put him in the squad. When you’ve got your best player on the bench and you’re 2-0 down at half-time, that’s the time to go, ‘Go on then, show me how much you care.’ He got that massively wrong.”
Air Cleared at Carrington Training Ground
According to reports from multiple outlets, Carrick and Fernandes met in person at Carrington to address the tension, and the manager has received backing to continue in his role.
Writing for The Athletic, Laurie Whitwell noted that those close to the pair believed they would address the issue directly, allowing a line to be drawn and making the captain available for the upcoming match at Stamford Bridge.
Sky Sports reporter Rob Dorsett shared on social media that the two individuals met face-to-face at the training ground to focus on reversing the team’s fortunes. Dorsett reported that an all-squad meeting also took place, where players acknowledged their poor performances and expressed a shared commitment to a fresh start.







