Michael Carrick will arrive at Stamford Bridge on Saturday with the air of a dead man walking as Manchester United sit fifth-bottom of the Premier League. Yet despite Chelsea holding fifth spot in the table, Opta’s expected points model indicates that the Blues have actually performed worse than their upcoming opponents this season.
Surprising Statistics Beneath the Surface
Opta’s data suggests Chelsea are currently the 12th-best team in the Premier League. Their rise to fifth place is the result of an exceptional finishing streak rather than dominant performances. Xabi Alonso’s side posted healthy expected goal margins in victories over Fulham, Brighton, and Everton, but they were heavily outgunned against Arsenal and Brentford. The expected goals count also went slightly against them versus Hull, Bournemouth, and Tottenham in home fixtures they would have expected to control.
Chelsea have scored 6.7 goals more than the quality of their chances suggests they deserve, placing them second only to Brighton in overperformance, or top if penalties are excluded. The team scored five times from 10 shots against Bournemouth, a feat that occurs less than once a season in the Premier League. Individual players are also outperforming historical metrics, with Jordan Henderson, Pedro Neto, and Morgan Rogers all scoring at rates unlikely to be maintained across another 30 league games.
Reliance on Key Players and Penalty Area Struggles
Adding João Pedro into the mix gives Chelsea four of the 12 players in the Premier League who sit at least 1.5 goals above their non-penalty expected goals this season. The two league games the Brazilian missed are the exact matches where Chelsea failed to score, generating a combined 1.3 expected goals against Brentford and Tottenham. João Pedro provides a vital focal point for the frontline, recording possession in the opposition penalty area 5.7 times per 90 minutes this season, the highest among centre-forwards with at least 400 minutes.
Estêvão Willian averages 5.8 touches in the opposition box, but the teenager has often been omitted. Meanwhile, Chelsea’s overall possession numbers have dwindled. After ranking third in the division for opposition box touches following four matches, they have dropped to eighth. While Premier League home teams average 27 touches per match in the box, Chelsea managed just 17 in their previous two matches at Stamford Bridge.
Possession Issues and Tactical Instability
Alonso has overseen three league matches where Chelsea recorded a maximum of 38% possession, compared to just four such games during nearly three years at Bayer Leverkusen. This trend does not stem purely from game states, as Chelsea held low possession shares even while building comfortable leads against Fulham and Brighton. Alonso acknowledged the issue prior to a Carabao Cup defeat at Anfield, stating, “You want to have possession. Knowing the context, knowing what we are building, I think that we have room for improvement in that part. We need to play more confidently with the ball.”
Historical data shows that achieving Champions League qualification with Chelsea’s current 46.5% possession average is extremely rare, with Leicester City’s title-winning side providing the only top-four precedent in the past 12 seasons. Tactical instability has compounded these issues, with Alonso alternating between a 3-4-3 and a 4-2-3-1 formation without using either for more than three consecutive league matches. Only Tottenham have averaged more changes to their starting lineup from game to game, and Chelsea have already started three different goalkeepers this season.
While uncertainty surrounds Manchester United and Carrick’s immediate future, Alonso faces plenty of questions of his own as he tries to stabilize Chelsea’s performances.
Source: Football | The Guardian







