Sky Sports pundit Gary Neville has condemned Manchester United’s handling of Michael Carrick’s departure, describing the club’s treatment of the former head coach as “disgusting.” The criticism comes as United moves to appoint Mauricio Pochettino as his successor.
Criticism of Club Leadership
Neville expressed his frustration that club executives were in Monaco pursuing Pochettino while Carrick was still leading training sessions in Manchester. Sky Sports News understands that United has reached an agreement in principle with Pochettino, with the club currently finalizing paperwork and regulatory processes with the US Soccer Federation.
Speaking on Sky Sports News, Neville stated that the club’s behavior fell well below professional standards. “In the last 24-48 hours it’s been spectacularly bad to be in Monaco as an executive and an owner whilst your manager, who’s a club legend, is taking training on the pitch and simultaneously approaching the US Soccer Federation to approach Mauricio Pochettino,” he said. He added that the situation reflected poorly on the club’s leadership, noting that in any other industry, such actions might be viewed as constructive dismissal.
Carrick, who was initially appointed in January following the departure of Ruben Amorim, secured a two-year contract after a successful run that included Champions League qualification. However, a difficult start to the current season, marked by three wins in 15 matches, led to his dismissal.
A Cycle of Failure
Neville acknowledged that Carrick must accept responsibility for the team’s poor results, which have left the club in the relegation zone. However, he emphasized that the issues at Old Trafford are systemic. Since Sir Alex Ferguson’s retirement in 2013, the club has seen numerous managers fail, and Neville believes fans have become numb to the recurring cycle of poor decision-making.
“I think this is a low but it just feels like you don’t even get angry anymore; you don’t get animated. You just feel like nothing,” Neville said. He pointed to the £1.6 billion spent on players over the last 13 years, arguing that the club’s recruitment strategy has been consistently flawed. He highlighted that the current squad lacks the necessary quality, particularly in midfield and defense, and noted that the club has struggled to offload underperforming players.
Advice for Pochettino
As Pochettino prepares to take over, Neville warned that a change in management alone will not resolve the club’s deep-seated problems. He urged the incoming coach to take firm control of recruitment and ensure he receives significant financial backing. “He’s got to come in here and protect himself against actually the people that he’s working with,” Neville advised. “He needs to make sure he takes the club into his own hands, into his own destiny.”
Neville suggested that Pochettino must act quickly to identify which players to build around and which to move on, drawing on his experience at Tottenham. He estimated that the squad requires a massive overhaul, potentially needing up to 10 new signings to become competitive again, including a complete defensive rebuild and further reinforcements in midfield and attack.
While Neville remains an admirer of Pochettino’s coaching ability and personality, he cautioned that the task at Old Trafford is monumental. He noted that the incoming manager must wipe the slate clean, as every previous attempt to restore the club to the top of English football—including those by experienced managers and club legends—has failed.
Pochettino is expected to begin his tenure as the club looks to move past the current period of instability.
Source: SkySports | News







