Manchester City Chief Executive Officer Ferran Soriano has reportedly rejected explanations regarding a secret 2017 gathering involving executives from Liverpool, Manchester United, and Arsenal. This meeting is viewed by some as crucial evidence supporting the existence of an alliance dubbed the “Red Cartel.”
The Backdrop of Financial Charges
An independent commission found Manchester City guilty of violating 114 Premier League rules last month. The panel concluded that the club utilized artificial sponsorship agreements to inflate earnings by approximately £900 million between 2009 and 2018. The club has appealed this decision, maintaining its innocence and asserting it possesses undeniable proof that sponsorship funds originated from the Abu Dhabi government rather than the club owners.
Potential sanctions face the club, ranging from fines, transfer bans, and point deductions to expulsion from the Premier League and stripping of titles, alongside the potential removal of owners by the Independent Football Regulator. When Soriano dismissed the commission’s findings last month, he referenced a conspiracy theory, which ESPN reports was aimed as much at traditional powerhouses Liverpool, Arsenal, and Manchester United as at the league itself.
The New York Dinner Meeting
Speculation regarding the “Red Cartel” has intensified following the guilty verdict. Manchester City stakeholders argue that these three major clubs colluded to hinder their ascent by lobbying for stringent financial fair play regulations.
A photograph captured by a diner at a Robert de Niro-co-owned New York restaurant serves as primary evidence for this theory. The image shows Manchester United owners Joel and Avram Glazer, former executive vice-chairman Ed Woodward, Liverpool owner John W. Henry, and former Arsenal chief executive Ivan Gazidis dining at Locanda Verde in Tribeca in October 2017.
This encounter occurred a week prior to a Premier League vote regarding future global broadcast revenue distribution. Although the “Big Six” collectively sought a larger share—which was ultimately secured in June 2018—the absence of Chelsea, Tottenham, and Manchester City from the dinner has been attributed to the three attending clubs sharing American ownership. However, sources told ESPN that Soriano and City’s leadership have consistently rejected this justification.
Perceived Bias and Media Frustration
Instead, leadership figures at Manchester City remain convinced that their rivals actively work to establish an environment that impedes City’s success. A source connected to City told ESPN that United, Arsenal, and Liverpool have feared losing their dominance over the league and transfer market from the beginning, noting that Sheikh Mansour’s 2008 arrival transformed the landscape and initiated ongoing friction.
Furthermore, sources claim City expressed dissatisfaction when senior figures at Manchester United and Liverpool were granted preferential access to candidates running to succeed Richard Scudamore as Premier League CEO. Although none of those candidates ultimately secured the position, City regards the access as evidence of systemic bias. Additional frustrations stem from what the club views as an excessive presence of former players from United, Liverpool, and Arsenal working in the media and frequently criticizing Manchester City.







