Manchester United manager Michael Carrick faces a crucial test ahead of Saturday’s away match against Chelsea as an eight-game winless run places his future under scrutiny. The team’s recent performances have raised questions about their identity and tactical direction following a difficult stretch of results.
Stop the High Press and Make United Harder to Play Through
One of the main challenges facing Carrick is that Manchester United are making life too simple for opponents by failing to execute a coordinated high press. United utilize a high block for 36 per cent of opposition build-up phases, ranking them among the Premier League’s most frequent users alongside Tottenham, Liverpool, and Manchester City. However, they have won the ball high up the pitch 52 times this season, yielding only 10 shots and no goals. Defeats to Atletico Madrid and Como exposed these defensive weaknesses when the first line of pressure is bypassed.
Bruno Fernandes questioned the decision not to press man-to-man against Como, but the solution requires a more consistent team structure rather than simply pressing higher. United have spent just 56.5 minutes in a high defensive compactness structure this season, the 18th-lowest in the Premier League. Implementing a more disciplined and compact approach similar to their performance against Leeds would help reduce gaps between defensive and midfield lines.
Bruno Fernandes Must Return to the Starting XI
Leaving Fernandes on the bench against Bournemouth drew significant attention, particularly after the captain questioned tactics following the defeat to Como. Although Carrick maintained it was a football decision, Fernandes’s absence coincided with another damaging loss, and he was not even introduced as the match slipped away. Clear-the-air talks between the pair have since resolved the disagreement, with Carrick confirming Fernandes remains captain.
While individual brilliance cannot permanently mask collective shortcomings, Fernandes remains essential for connecting the midfield and attack. His ability to create chances and progress possession is vital when United struggle to break down organised defences, making his return to the starting lineup difficult to omit if he is fit.
Turn to Youth?
Senior players who previously carried United are currently struggling to deliver consistent performances, opening the door for younger squad members to inject energy and conviction. Harry Amass impressed during pre-season and represents an option at left-back, while 19-year-old Shea Lacey offers enthusiasm and a willingness to take responsibility after previously scoring against Brighton in the Carabao Cup.
While introducing youngsters into a struggling side carries risks, Carrick may need to look beyond experienced players who are underperforming. Combining youthful energy with the quality of Fernandes could provide the necessary balance for the squad.
Go Back to Basics and Stop Moving Players Around
United have frequently shifted players into new positions this season, complicating efforts to find form and tactical consistency. Diogo Dalot has played on both flanks, Leny Yoro has featured at right-back and centre-back, Mason Mount has operated on the right, and Youri Tielemans has moved into advanced midfield roles. Further forward, Matheus Cunha and Bryan Mbeumo have also spent time away from their preferred positions.
Constant reshuffling has prevented the establishment of reliable partnerships on the pitch. Ahead of the trip to Chelsea, Carrick needs to deploy his strongest available eleven in natural roles to build a stable foundation for the team.
Source: SkySports | News







