While football supporters usually celebrate when their team wins a penalty, Newport County fans face the spot kick with apprehension. The Welsh club has converted just two of nine penalties across all competitions over the past two seasons, leaving them with a 16.7% success rate that ranks as the worst in the entire English Football League.
Struggles from the Spot
The dismal run includes missing five of their last six penalties in League Two, a troubling statistic for a side sitting just two points outside the play-offs. Three different managers and multiple designated penalty takers have attempted to solve the issue without success. Hope arose in October when Harrison Biggins scored from the spot in a draw against Rotherham, but optimism vanished four days later when the midfielder had his effort saved in a 1-0 defeat to Cheltenham Town after choosing the same side.
Manager Hayden Mullins expressed sympathy for his players, noting that taking penalties remains a psychological duel. As a former player for clubs like Crystal Palace, West Ham, and Portsmouth, Mullins understands the pressure firsthand. He noted that a taker must pick a side and execute the shot with aggression while playing a game of cat and mouse with the opposing goalkeeper.
Predictable Patterns and Past Success
Recent statistics indicate a predictable pattern, with six of Newport’s last nine penalties directed to the right. Goalkeepers have guessed correctly every time, denying Cameron Antwi, Nathaniel Opoku, Bobby Kamwa, and Shaquille Gwengwe. Alternative tactics have fared little better, as Ged Garner was stopped to the left against Swindon Town, while Yahya Bamba saw an attempt into the top corner disallowed for a double touch before scoring the subsequent retake.
The club’s current struggles contrast sharply with their form between 2023 and 2025, when forwards Will Evans and Omar Bogle successfully converted 10 out of 13 penalties. Mullins typically entrusts his centre-forward with spot-kick duties, though the team missed two penalties during a recent three-match suspension for Gwengwe.
Gwengwe returns to availability for the upcoming fixture, with Mullins confirming the striker spends extended time practicing penalties after training sessions. Despite the ongoing issues, the manager stated he refuses to dwell excessively on the conversion rate. He highlighted that success depends on numerous factors, including fatigue, mindset, match context, and the opponent, and emphasized that the squad will continue practicing to prepare for the next opportunity.
Source: BBC Sport







