The history of football as a team sport changed significantly in 1963 with a tactical foul by Milan forward Gino Pivatelli in the European Cup final against Benfica. That moment marked the rise of systems over individuals, making modern football resolutely a team game.
The Paradox of Individual Awards
The tension between individual brilliance and the collective has always made individual awards like the Ballon d’Or an oddity. When the award launched in 1956, that paradox was less pronounced, though the Hungarian vote was split amidst political turmoil as Soviet tanks entered Budapest.
The choice of 38-year-old Stanley Matthews as the inaugural winner looked unusual from a modern perspective. While Blackpool finished second in the First Division in 1956, they trailed Manchester United by 11 points and exited the FA Cup early, raising questions over whether other standout performers deserved the recognition instead.
Judging Criteria and Team Success
According to official criteria, the Ballon d’Or rests on individual performance, team achievements, and fair play. Isolating team achievement remains complex, particularly with dominant clubs like Paris Saint-Germain where multiple exceptional players share the load.
While Arsenal achieved remarkable success by winning the Premier League and reaching the Champions League final, their strength lies in the collective. Similarly, Spain claimed the World Cup through midfield unity, while major clubs like Real Madrid endured trophyless campaigns, complicating the cases of their star players.
The Case for Harry Kane
In a season lacking an obvious dominant candidate from a triumphant super-team, the panel may look to consistency and individual drive, much like they did in 1956. Jonathan Wilson writes that Harry Kane presents a strong case despite Bayern Munich and England falling short of ultimate team trophies.
Scoring 61 goals in 51 club matches last season alongside six goals at the World Cup, Kane carried his teams forward through sheer individual will. In a year without a clear standout from a trophy-winning juggernaut, the panel could well reward longevity and consistent excellence.
Source: Football | The Guardian







