Dundee United’s impressive midfield trio sparked discussions over whether they are the best in the Scottish Premiership following a 2-2 draw against league leaders Celtic. Jim Goodwin’s side extended their unbeaten run to six matches at Celtic Park, though they subsequently slipped to fifth in the standings after city rivals Dundee defeated Kilmarnock 3-1. Despite missing out on a historic first away victory against Celtic since 1992, Goodwin, Celtic counterpart Martin O’Neill, and BBC pundits expressed high praise for the team’s performance.
Midfield Control and Composure
The central partnership of Zidane Iqbal, Lyall Cameron, and Dylan Tait dominated the opening half before Celtic introduced wingers Jota and Haissem Hassan after the interval to shift the momentum. On BBC Radio Scotland’s Sportsound, chief sports writer Tom English raised the question of whether Dundee United feature the finest midfield three in Scotland.
Former United wing-back Allan Preston lauded the unit, highlighting Iqbal’s performance. As reported by BBC Sport, Preston said: “Iqbal in that first half especially was pulling the strings and Celtic couldn’t get near him. Iqbal is like a watch battery. He keeps everything ticking. He sits off and just passes it from side to side. Very rarely gives the ball way.”
Goodwin praised his players’ composure, while former United midfielder Scott Allan noted that Iraq international Iqbal—a former Manchester United youth player signed from Utrecht—operates effectively alongside Tait and on-loan Rangers player Cameron. Allan stated on Sportscene that the three players share the same wavelength, showing bravery and quality during the first half by inviting pressure and moving the ball smoothly.
Managerial Impact and Future Prospects
Allan also commended Goodwin for executing a well-designed gameplan, noting that although Celtic’s substitutions forced Dundee United into a defensive battle in the second half, the visitors held firm. Former Celtic goalkeeper Pat Bonner agreed that Dundee United deserved their point, describing them as an organized side with strong players across the pitch.
Goodwin reflected on missing out on the top six by one place last season, explaining that observing Jens Berthel Askou’s success at Motherwell inspired a tactical shift in style for the current campaign. After a slow start that yielded just one win in seven matches, the team’s current six-game unbeaten streak has left Goodwin satisfied with October’s points return, despite lingering disappointment over failing to secure a historic win.
Reflecting on the match, Goodwin stated that responding to an early goal demonstrated strong character, adding that the squad had to dig deep during a relentless final 20 minutes from Celtic. Martin O’Neill, who previously managed Goodwin as a youth player, offered high praise after the match, describing him as a very fine manager who has done a remarkable job.
Source: BBC Sport







